The U.S. Impact Investing Alliance submitted a formal comment letter to the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission opposing its proposal to rescind Rule 14a-8, which governs shareholder proposals, and to amend Rule 14a-4(c).
For more than eighty years, Rule 14a-8 has given investors a predictable, low-cost way to place proposals in a company’s proxy statement for a vote by their fellow shareholders. As the Commission itself acknowledges, voting by proxy has largely replaced attendance at shareholder meetings, and for most investors, a proposal that cannot reach the proxy statement cannot reach a vote at all.
“Rule 14a-8 is one of the most important tools investors have to engage with corporate management,” said Fran Seegull, President of the U.S. Impact Investing Alliance. “Shareholder proposals are how investors raise material risks that matter to the long-term health of the companies they own. Shareholder voice is not a regulatory burden to be minimized; it is a source of the trust that makes U.S. capital markets the strongest in the world.”
The Commission has clear authority to maintain the rule. Rescission would replace an orderly federal process with costly, fragmented litigation and chill the engagement between companies and investors that the rule makes possible. The rescission proposal rests on an economic analysis that counts the savings to issuers while leaving the costs to investors largely unquantified. The Alliance also opposes the companion amendments to Rule 14a-4(c), which would give management a default vote on the very proposals that rescission pushes outside the company’s proxy statement.
The Alliance urged the Commission to withdraw both proposals. The letter builds on the Alliance’s September request for a 120-day comment period and a public hearing, and on its comments earlier this year urging the Commission to preserve its disclosure framework under Regulation S-K.
Read the Alliance’s full comments here.
